| J.L. Truesdale | 1886 | J.H. Warne | 1931 | Lyle K. Orr Jr. | 1976 |
| S.S. Macklin | 1887 | R.A. Manchester II | 1932 | Joseph P. Fergus | 1977 |
| S.S. Macklin | 1888 | J.W. Walker | 1933 | Henry S. Fletcher | 1978 |
| D. Campbell | 1889 | A. Francis | 1934 | Russell W. Gillam Jr. | 1979 |
| E.N. Brown | 1890 | N.V. McMillin | 1935 | Donald J. Hammond | 1980 |
| W.A. Gee | 1891 | Thomas Halton | 1936 | Elmer J. Stalnacker Jr. | 1981 |
| H.A. Manchester | 1892 | I.E. Ruhlman | 1937 | Donald R. Damicone | 1982 |
| J.S. Caldwell | 1893 | J.B. Jones | 1938 | Michael L. Rahe | 1983 |
| J.C. Kirk | 1894 | Wm. McMasters | 1939 | Robert L. Fry | 1984 |
| C.C. Fowler | 1895 | H.F. Webster | 1940 | Donald L. Huntley | 1985 |
| M.V.B. King | 1896 | W.B. Gallaher | 1941 | Gregory B. Anstrom | 1986 |
| J.C. Miller | 1897 | R.F. Fisher | 1942 | Douglas F. Anstrom | 1987 |
| John Delfs | 1898 | D.H. Williams | 1943 | Donald C. Sundin | 1988 |
| J.C. Nash | 1899 | P.O. White | 1944 | Richard E. Ranshaw | 1989 |
| I.A. Manchester | 1900 | R.W. Johnson | 1945 | Mark D. Stovall | 1990 |
| A.S. Porter | 1901 | Emery Reese | 1946 | Paul H. Connelly | 1991 |
| H.T. Hawkins | 1902 | R.D. Wilcox | 1947 | Timothy D. Ensign | 1992 |
| Geo. A. Blair | 1903 | J.R. Marshall | 1948 | Gregory B. Smith Sr. | 1993 |
| J.S. Handte | 1904 | N.J. McKibben | 1949 | Marvin D. Rader | 1994 |
| W.A. Gee | 1905 | Don Graham | 1950 | Thomas M. Jackson | 1995 |
| J.C. Miller | 1906 | Cecil F. Gill | 1951 | Russell W. Gillam III | 1996 |
| J.B. Hollis | 1907 | E.G. Dennison | 1952 | Thomas R. Couche Jr. | 1997 |
| W.L. Bryson | 1908 | Homer J. Price | 1953 | Kyle L. Rogers | 1998 |
| Aaron Wiesner | 1909 | Earl Tom Brown | 1954 | Stephen H. Oleksiuk | 1999 |
| W.A. Gee | 1910 | Roy R. Richards | 1955 | Paul L. McGraw | 2000 |
| W.A. Gee | 1911 | C.R. Gibbons | 1956 | Thomas J. Hallden | 2001 |
| Herbert Delfs | 1912 | Anthony V. Sebastian | 1957 | Kevin A. Hallden | 2002 |
| S.A. Arnold | 1913 | Howard M. Conner | 1958 | Dale E. Hawkins | 2003 |
| F.A. Morris | 1914 | Robt. W. Tener Jr. | 1959 | Robert A. Edwards | 2004 |
| L.B. Curtis | 1915 | W.W. Marriott | 1960 | Terry D. Crosby Jr. | 2005 |
| C.H. Campbell | 1916 | John P. Leach | 1961 | Michael D. McCarthy | 2006 |
| E.A. Arnold | 1917 | Martin Miklis | 1962 | George E. Brainard | 2007 |
| E.R. Zieger | 1918 | Robert Morton | 1963 | Greg M. Foley | 2008 |
| P.G. Wilcox | 1919 | Wilfred Stephenson Sr. | 1964 | Christopher J. Brocious | 2009 |
| D.B. Fowler | 1920 | Thomas R. Couche | 1965 | R. Christopher Gillam | 2010 |
| R.D. Fowler | 1921 | Lloyd T. Vandervoort | 1966 | Richard B. Percic | 2011 |
| H.S. Manchester | 1922 | Gary L. Smith | 1967 | Thomas J. Hallden | 2012 |
| H.I. Hine | 1923 | Lyle K. Orr Sr. | 1968 | Russell W. Gillam Jr. | 2013 |
| A.K. Osborn | 1924 | G. Don Terry | 1969 | Mark R. Roca | 2014 |
| T.C. Rose | 1925 | Wallace R. Moore | 1970 | Dale E. Hawkins | 2015 |
| H.T. Silver | 1926 | Walter S. Finnie | 1971 | Ryan H. Hamilton | 2016 |
| A.E. Gross | 1927 | Harold W. Vandersall | 1972 | Chuck Prachick | 2017 |
| P.H. Whitmore | 1928 | Thomas C. Creese IV | 1973 | Eric Cahalin | 2018 |
| S.P. Drake | 1929 | Clifford G. Swartz | 1974 | Richard Palmer | 2019 |
| H.R. Raymond | 1930 | James L. Huckle | 1975 | William S. Golec | 2020 |
| Daniel R. Gibboney | 2021 | ||||
| Wayne Unger | 2022 | ||||
| Daniel Illencik | 2023 | ||||
| Mark Pesut | 2024 | ||||
